THE QUICK BREAKDOWN
Understand both positions
Removing standings may emphasize learning and participation. Keeping score can make games meaningful and teach resilience, teamwork and sportsmanship.
AThe case for “Focus on development”
Supporters prioritize the benefits represented by this choice and believe its advantages outweigh the risks or limitations.
BThe case for “Competition teaches lessons”
Supporters of this position place greater weight on the alternative risks, trade-offs and possible unintended consequences.
Keep in mindA strong answer depends on evidence, circumstances and which trade-off matters most—not simply which side is more popular.
THE CONVERSATION
Why people chose their side
Choose a side above to join the discussion.